Saturday, March 12, 2005

Guantanamo not so bad

The Pentagon wants to get rid of a number of Guatanamo detainees by sending them to Saudi Arabia, Yemen and Afganistan. Imprisonment in these countries will not be pleasant:
The Pentagon is planning to transfer half the inmates at Guantánamo Bay to prisons in Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan and Yemen, despite fears that they would face even worse human rights abuses than at the US camp.
The "keep them at GTMO" outcry has aleady started
Michael Rattner, president of the Centre for Constitutional Rights, which represents many of the Guantánamo detainees, said: "Now that they have put themselves in this pickle of picking up many people who were not involved in terrorism, and keeping them for two or three years and abusing them in a number of cases, what are they going to do with them? Send them back to countries where governments are known to be involved in torture, with a label of terrorist practically around their neck?

"We don't want people rendered, or given their so-called freedom from Guantánamo, and then jailed in a country where they are going to be tortured."
Funny how things change.

2 Comments:

Anonymous Jorgen said...

There is no problem:
1) "Under the Yemeni Constitution, the practice of physical and psychological torture is prohibited, as is the extraction of confessions by force during investigations...". http://www.unhchr.ch/huricane/huricane.nsf/0/35DE9E23517181B3C1256DE1005A0284?opendocument

2)The US is in a good position to ask the Afghans not to use torture (though they probably has signed the UN treaty on torture).

3) According to Amnesty Int. "Saudi Arabia has signed up to three major international human rights treaties on
torture,...".

If there later should be a problem, it can be taken up by the UN.

8:38 PM  
Anonymous J F Beck said...

I agree, let the UN set up a committee or two to sort things out.

10:42 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home